Opens 1 December. Book a demo.

17 Nov 2026 · Global · Article

How do regulators judge misleading ad claims?

They judge the overall impression an ad creates and whether the advertiser can support every claim with evidence.

Regulators judge an ad claim by the overall impression it leaves on the people it targets, not only by its literal words, and they expect the advertiser to be able to support every claim with evidence. Two cases published on 16 November 2026 show both tests at work: Poland’s consumer authority UOKiK charged Grupa Maspex over its Kubuś Waterrr drink ads, and in the US the National Advertising Review Board (NARB) said it will refer Harry’s maker Mammoth Brands to regulators, including the Federal Trade Commission.

What do regulators look at first in an ad claim?

They look at the message a typical viewer takes away from the whole ad. That means the product name, colours, images, slogans and the audience all count, not just the sentence a lawyer approved.

UOKiK’s President, Tomasz Chróstny, put it plainly when announcing the charges: what matters in advertising is not only what the business says about the product, but also the impression it creates. In the Kubuś Waterrr case, the authority listed several elements that together could suggest the drink contains only a small addition of fruit juice:

  • the name Waterrr itself, which points to water;
  • blue colour schemes and water motifs;
  • bottles of a clear, colourless drink shown in the ads, which the label explains is clarified and filtered.

According to UOKiK, apple juice makes up 30 per cent of Kubuś Waterrr and 25 per cent of Kubuś Waterrr Active+. That is the gap between the impression and the product that the authority objects to.

The NARB case in the US makes the same point from another angle. The panel did not stop at the literal wording of the Harry’s claims about “Gillette users”. It asked what comparison the ads implied overall, and concluded they presented Harry’s Plus as a satisfactory shaving alternative at a lower price. In the panel’s reading, that was a comparison of the overall value of the two brands rather than of performance or preference.

Can a true statement still mislead?

Yes. The Kubuś Waterrr case turns on claims that may be accurate in isolation but can still leave a false picture.

UOKiK gave two examples. First, fruit graphics on bottles and in ads for raspberry or strawberry flavours could suggest those fruits dominate the juice content. In fact, according to the authority, juice from those fruits accounts for just 0.1 per cent, and apple juice is the main fruit ingredient. Second, the “zero added sugar” claim on the packaging highlights the words “zero” and “sugar”, while the word “added” appears in much smaller type. A shopper could conclude the drink contains no sugar at all, even though fruit juices contain sugars. UOKiK cited the World Health Organization recommendation that free sugars, which include both added sugars and those naturally present in fruit juice, should stay below 10 per cent of total energy intake.

Chróstny said that even true information can create a misleading impression when presented in a certain way. UOKiK also stated that having the composition printed on the label does not excuse the business from communicating honestly in its ads. In other words, small print on the pack does not repair a misleading headline in the campaign.

Audience matters too. The Kubuś Waterrr campaigns ran on television, online and on social media with slogans about hydration, quenching thirst and training, showed children at play and doing sport, involved influencers, and were aimed mainly at children and their parents. UOKiK said the combination of name, presentation and slogans could suggest the drinks can be used the same way as water, for example in a child’s bottle for the playground or a bike ride. Because of the juice content, the authority said, they are not an equivalent of water.

What evidence do you need behind a claim?

You need evidence in the record that supports the specific message the ad conveys. Claims with that support survived review; claims without it did not.

In the Harry’s case, Gillette challenged several claims built on a home-use survey, such as the share of “Gillette users” who said they “would shave with” Harry’s Plus and who liked how it felt. The National Advertising Division (NAD) first found these claims did not convey the implied comparisons Gillette alleged. On appeal, the NARB panel agreed that the survey results backed the “would shave with” claims. It added a condition: where Harry’s cites study data about Gillette users, it should draw on the figures for the brands respondents used most often. That is a useful detail, because the panel cared about exactly which survey subgroup sat behind the words “Gillette users”.

The pricing claims fared worse. NAD had found the language somewhat hyperbolic but supported. The NARB panel disagreed on parts of it. It recommended Harry’s stop using the phrases “ripped off” and “taking advantage of you” when aimed, directly or by implication, at a specific competitor such as Gillette, because the record held no evidence of any such intent by Gillette. The panel also found that a commercial dismissing the Gillette razor as little more than some metal and plastic belittled the product’s value and performance with no support in the record. It recommended dropping that language, and the Gillette Labs commercial itself.

The lesson is straightforward. In this case, exaggeration aimed at a named rival needed proof like any other claim about that rival.

What Who When Where Source
Charges over the promotion of Kubuś Waterrr and Kubuś Waterrr Active+ UOKiK President against Grupa Maspex 16 Nov 2026 Poland UOKiK news
Apple juice share stated as 30% (Waterrr) and 25% (Active+) UOKiK 16 Nov 2026 Poland UOKiK news
Raspberry or strawberry juice share stated as 0.1% UOKiK 16 Nov 2026 Poland UOKiK news
Possible fine of up to 10% of annual turnover UOKiK 16 Nov 2026 Poland UOKiK news
Survey-based “would shave with” claims about “Gillette users” found supported NARB panel, Mammoth Brands (Harry’s) 16 Nov 2026 US BBB National Programs, National Advertising Division
Disparaging pricing language and Gillette Labs commercial recommended for discontinuation NARB panel, Mammoth Brands (Harry’s) 16 Nov 2026 US BBB National Programs, National Advertising Division
Referral to regulators including the FTC NARB, Mammoth Brands 16 Nov 2026 US BBB National Programs, National Advertising Division

What happens when an advertiser will not comply?

The case moves from self-regulation to a government regulator. In the US, NARB refers advertisers who do not confirm compliance to the appropriate authorities.

Mammoth Brands said it would carefully consider both decisions when reviewing current and future advertising, but stated it was “not able to make an unqualified commitment” to follow the panel’s recommendations. As a result, NARB will pass the company to regulators, the Federal Trade Commission among them. The referral is the escalation step.

In Poland, UOKiK is the regulator, so there is no intermediate step. The Maspex case is at the charges stage, which means the authority has set out its concerns and no decision or fine has been announced. If UOKiK finds an infringement of the collective interests of consumers, the law allows a fine of up to 10 per cent of annual turnover.

What should you do this month?

Audit every live campaign for the impression it creates and the evidence behind each claim, starting with these steps.

  1. Review each live campaign as a viewer would: list the name, colours, images and slogans together, write down the message they create, and check it against the actual product.
  2. Find any claim where a key word sits in smaller type, such as “added”, “from” or “up to”, and test whether the headline alone would mislead.
  3. Build an evidence file for every claim before launch, recording the exact data subgroup behind phrases like “users of brand X”.
  4. Remove or rewrite any line that attributes bad intent or poor quality to a named competitor unless you hold documented proof.
  5. Give extra scrutiny to ads that feature or target children, including influencer content, and check every market you run in, since Poland and the US apply these tests through different bodies.

See how we set up a regulatory check for your market

Questions

Does putting the full ingredients on the label protect the ad?
Not according to UOKiK. The authority said that composition details on the Kubuś Waterrr labels do not release Grupa Maspex from the duty to communicate honestly in its advertising.
What penalty can UOKiK impose in Poland?
For infringing the collective interests of consumers, a business faces a fine of up to 10 per cent of its annual turnover. The Maspex case is at the charges stage, so no fine has been set.
Is NARB a government regulator?
No. NARB is the appellate body of BBB National Programs, which runs advertising self-regulation in the US. When an advertiser will not commit to its recommendations, it refers the case to regulators such as the Federal Trade Commission.
Does it matter if an ad features children?
UOKiK paid close attention to it. The Kubuś Waterrr campaigns showed children playing and doing sport, used influencers, and were aimed mainly at children and their parents, which shaped how the authority read the hydration slogans.
Can I compare my product with a named rival?
Yes, if the comparison is supported. The NARB panel accepted Harry's survey-based "would shave with" claims about "Gillette users" but rejected language that attacked Gillette without evidence in the record.

Source

Author

Taras Kopytko, Founder, PackCraft

Published 17 Nov 2026

We turn changes like this into your monthly content plan. You approve every piece.

Book a demoMore from Insights